Press Releases
Magyar Telekom announces further updates on the investigation
Budapest, December 21, 2006 08:00
Magyar Telekom announces further updates on the investigation.
On February 13, 2006, the Company announced that it was initiating an
investigation into certain contracts to determine whether they were
entered into in violation of Company policy or applicable law or
regulation. This investigation has been carried out under the
supervision of the Company’s Audit Committee by a prominent
international law firm, with the assistance of a financial advisory
firm and a digital forensics firm. The investigators have delivered an
Initial Report of Investigation. The Company cannot predict when the
investigation will be concluded or what the final findings will be.
Concerns
regarding two consultancy contracts entered into in 2005 by the
Company’s Montenegrin subsidiaries Telekom Crne Gore A.D. (“TCG”) and
Monet d.o.o. (“Monet”) were initially raised by the Company’s auditors.
The initial scope of the investigation was a complete review of these
two contracts, including a review of all related documents and
interviews with Company, TCG and Monet employees and third parties with
knowledge of the contracts. The financial advisory firm also reviewed a
sampling of account and transactional data at the Company and its
Montenegrin subsidiaries, equaling 72% of the value of all transactions
and 90% of the value of all contracts with third party vendors. For
each of these test items, all available supporting documentation was
reviewed. Early in the investigation, two additional consultancy
contracts, which were entered into in 2005 by the Company, were also
called into question by the investigators, and the Audit Committee
expanded the scope of the investigation to cover these contracts. The
total value of the four contracts under investigation is approximately
HUF 2 billion.
During the course of the investigation, it
became evident that certain employees at the Company, TCG and Monet had
impeded the investigation by destroying or tampering with electronic
documents. Specifically, the digital forensics firm assisting the
investigation found that ten computers assigned to seven employees
showed evidence that documents had been deleted from the hard drives
and “wiping” software used to make those documents permanently
unrecoverable. Investigators have determined that the deleted
electronic documents included a number of documents related to the
contracts under investigation. This deletion and wiping activity took
place after the Company had issued document retention memos requiring
that all documents related to these contracts be retained. As a result
of this deliberate destruction of documents, the investigators have
been unable to review documents that would have been relevant to the
investigation.
To date, the independent investigators have
been unable to find sufficient evidence to show that any of the four
contracts under investigation resulted in the provision of services to
the Company or its subsidiaries of a value commensurate with the
payments made under those contracts.
It is unclear who the true
counterparties are to the contracts, and certain of the contracts are
vague as to the actual services that are to be provided to the
Company.
The independent investigators have been unable to determine
definitively the purpose of the contracts, and it is possible that the
purpose may have been improper. On the basis of the findings to date,
the concerns of the Company auditors were well founded.
In its
2005 preliminary results announcement, the Company had capitalized the
HUF 1.12 billion payment related to two of these contracts. As a result
of the interim findings of the investigation, the Company has now
expensed the total amount of the HUF 2 billion paid under these four
contracts and disclosed these expenses under the caption “Other
operating expenses – net.” This has resulted in a commensurate effect
on, among other items, taxes, minority interest and net income when
compared to the corresponding items reported in the Company’s 2005
preliminary results announcement.
As a consequence of the
investigation, the Company has suspended a number of employees who have
since resigned. The suspended employees included members of the
Company’s Strategy Group and an executive of TCG. As has been announced
previously, the TCG Board of Directors has also been replaced.
In
the course of their investigation, the investigators also identified
several contracts at another subsidiary that might warrant further
review.
The investigation has revealed certain weaknesses in
the design and operation of the Company's internal controls and
procedures. Accordingly, The Company has approved and is currently
implementing certain remedial measures designed to enhance its internal
controls and compliance and governance regime, including the following:
First, the position of Magyar Telekom Group Compliance Director has
been created, reporting directly to the Company Chief Financial
Officer, the Supervisory Board and the Audit Committee. In conjunction
with this new position, the Company is reviewing its policies and
establishing a comprehensive compliance-training program, with a focus
on the Company Code of Ethics, insider trading policy, document
retention policy, regulatory matters, and compliance with the U.S.
Foreign Corrupt Practices Act. Second, the Company is revising its
internal controls relating to procurement, including access to all SAP
systems of subsidiaries and a requirement that all contract approvals
pass through uniform rules and procedures. Third, the Company has
revised its mergers and acquisitions process, including dividing
accountability for M&A between the Strategy Group, which will
remain responsible for business development, and the area of the Chief
Financial Officer, which will be responsible for execution of M&A
transactions. All M&A activity will require Board approval and will
be reported to the Audit Committee on a semi-annual basis. Finally, the
Company Board may make further decisions or recommendations in
connection with the involvement of any senior management in the four
contracts under investigation.
As previously reported, the
investigation has delayed the finalization of the Company’s 2005
financial statements, and as a result the Company and some of its
subsidiaries have failed and may fail to meet certain deadlines
prescribed by U.S., Hungarian and other applicable laws and regulations
for preparing and filing audited annual results and holding annual
general meetings. The Company has to date been fined HUF 12 million as
a consequence of these delays. The Company has notified the Hungarian
Financial Supervisory Authority, the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission and the U.S. Department of Justice about the investigation,
is in contact with these authorities regarding the investigation and is
responding to inquiries raised by these authorities.