Investor Releases
Magyar Telekom Announces Receipt of Final Report of the Audit Committee’s Internal Investigation
Budapest, December 3, 2009 08:20
Magyar Telekom Nyrt. (the “Company”) (Reuters: NYSE: MTA.N, BÉT: MTEL.BU and Bloomberg: NYSE: MTA US, BÉT: MTELEKOM HB), the
leading Hungarian
telecommunications service provider announces that the Company’s Audit
Committee has issued the final report of its independent internal investigation
into certain contracts relating to advisory, marketing, acquisition
due-diligence and/or lobbying services in Montenegro and Macedonia.
Background
In
the course of conducting their audit of the Company’s 2005 financial
statements, PricewaterhouseCoopers, the Company’s auditors, identified two
contracts the nature and business purposes of which were not readily apparent
to them. In February 2006, the Company’s Audit Committee retained White & Case,
as its independent legal counsel, to conduct an internal investigation into
whether the Company had made payments under those, or other contracts,
potentially prohibited by U.S.
laws or regulations, including FCPA or internal Company policy. The Company’s
Audit Committee also informed the United States Department of Justice (“DOJ”),
the United States
Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”) and the Hungarian Financial
Supervisory Authority of the internal investigation.
Based
on the documentation and other evidence obtained by it, White & Case
preliminarily concluded that there was reason to believe that four consulting
contracts entered into in 2005 were entered into to serve improper objectives,
and further found that during 2006 certain employees had destroyed evidence
that was relevant to the investigation. White & Case also identified
several contracts at our Macedonian subsidiary that could warrant further
review. In February 2007, our Board of Directors determined that those
contracts should be reviewed and expanded the scope of the internal
investigation to cover these additional contracts and any related or similarly
questionable contracts or payments.
For
further information about the internal and governmental investigations, please
refer to the Company’s quarterly reports for the first, second and third
quarters of 2009 and the Company’s annual reports on Form 20-F for the year
ended December 31, 2008 filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission.
Findings and Conclusions of the Audit
Committee's Internal Investigation
On
December 2, 2009, the Audit Committee provided the Company’s Board of Directors
with a “Report of Investigation to the Audit Committee of Magyar Telekom Nyrt.”
dated November 30, 2009 (the “Final Report”).
The Audit Committee indicated that it considers that, with the
preparation of the Final Report based on currently available facts, White &
Case has completed its independent internal investigation.
The
Final Report includes the following findings and conclusions, based upon the
evidence available to the Audit Committee and its counsel:
- As previously disclosed, with respect to Montenegrin contracts, there is “insufficient evidence to establish that the approximately EUR 7 million in expenditures made pursuant to four consultancy contracts ... were made for legitimate business purposes”, and there is “affirmative evidence that these expenditures served improper purposes.” These contracts were not appropriately recorded in the books and records of the Company and its relevant subsidiaries. As previously disclosed, the Company has already reclassified, in the Company’s financial statements, the accounting treatment relating to certain of these contracts to more accurately account for these expenditures.
- As previously disclosed, there is evidence that certain former employees intentionally destroyed documents relating to activities undertaken in Macedonia by the Company and its affiliates.
- Between
2000 and 2006 a
small group of former senior executives at the Company and the Company’s
Macedonian affiliates, authorized the expenditure of approximately EUR 24
million through over twenty suspect consultancy, lobbying, and other contracts
(including certain contracts between the Company and its subsidiaries on one
hand, and affiliates of a Cyprus-based consulting company on the other
hand). The Final Report concludes that
“the available evidence does not establish that the contracts under which these
expenditures were made were legitimate.”
- “The evidence shows that, contrary to their terms, a number of these contracts were undertaken to obtain specific regulatory and other benefits from the government of Macedonia. The Companies generally received the benefits sought and then made expenditures under one or more of the suspect contracts. There is evidence that the remaining contracts were also illegitimate and created a pool of funds available for purposes other than those stated on the face of the agreements.” However, the Audit Committee’s counsel did not have access to evidence that would allow it to identify the ultimate beneficiaries of these expenditures.
- In entering into these
contracts and approving expenditures under them, the former senior
executives knowingly caused, structured, or approved transactions that
shared most or all of the following characteristics:
- intentional circumvention of internal controls;
- false and misleading
Company documents and records;
- lack of due diligence
concerning, and failure to monitor performance of, contractors and agents
in circumstances carrying a high risk of corruption;
lack of evidence of performance; and
- expenditures that were not for the purposes stated in the contracts under which they were made, but rather were intended to obtain benefits for the Companies that could only be conferred by government action.
- The Final Report states that “the Investigation did not uncover evidence showing receipt of payments by any Macedonian government officials or political party officials.”
Nothing
in the Final Report implicates any current senior executive or Board member of
the Company in connection with any wrongdoing.
The
Company continues to consider the findings and conclusions of the Final
Report. The Company is considering the
impact, if any, of the findings and conclusions of the internal investigation
on the Company’s current and past financial statements and other disclosures.
As
previously disclosed, the Company has taken remedial steps to address issues
previously identified by the independent investigation, including steps
designed to revise and enhance the Company’s internal controls. In connection with the issuance of the Final
Report, the Audit Committee has not made recommendations relating to the
Company’s compliance program or internal controls. The Company is considering whether and to
what extent the Final Report warrants additional remedial actions and, pursuant
to the Audit Committee’s request, the Company will present to the Audit
Committee for its consideration any personnel actions and/or changes in
internal control policies and procedures at the Company or its subsidiaries
that have been or will be implemented to address the findings of the Final
Report.
The
Company is continuing to assess the nature and scope of potential legal
remedies available to the Company against individuals or entities that may have
caused harm to the Company.
Other Related Matters
As
previously announced, the DOJ, the SEC and the Ministry of Interior of the Republic of Macedonia have commenced investigations
into certain of the Company’s activities that were the subject of the internal
investigation. Also, as previously
announced, the Hungarian National Bureau of Investigation (“NBI”) has begun a
criminal investigation into alleged misappropriation of funds relating to
payments made in connection with the Company’s ongoing internal investigation
and the possible misuse of personal data of employees in the context of the
internal investigation. These
governmental investigations are continuing, and the Company continues to
cooperate with those investigations. The
Company cannot predict what the final outcome of those investigations may be or
the impact, if any, they may have on our financial statements or results of
operations. Furthermore, government authorities could seek criminal or civil
sanctions, including monetary penalties, against us or our affiliates as well
as additional changes to our business practices and compliance programs.
This investor news contains forward-looking statements. Statements that are not historical facts, including statements about our beliefs and expectations, are forward-looking statements. These statements are based on current plans, estimates and projections, and therefore should not have undue reliance placed upon them. Forward-looking statements speak only as of the date they are made, and we undertake no obligation to update publicly any of them in light of new information or future events.
Forward-looking statements involve inherent risks and uncertainties. We caution you that a number of important factors could cause actual results to differ materially from those contained in any forward-looking statement. Such factors are described in, among other things, our Annual Report on Form 20-F for the year ended December 31, 2008 filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission.